Back to blog

The Role of Recruiters: Strategies for Making a Lasting Impression

The Role of Recruiters: Strategies for Making a Lasting Impression
Jill Wells
For Candidates

You know the saying, “You never get a second chance to make a first impression?” This statement is especially true when you’re job hunting. From facial expressions to lack of eye contact or arriving at a meeting on time, working with a recruiter must be reciprocal.

A recruiter’s job is to use professional networking strategies to sell you to potential employers, and to do that, you’ll need to be a good fit for them and leave them with a good impression. It’s essential to approach a new relationship with a recruiter as you would approach a new job, taking steps to impress them from the moment you walk into the office.

But what are some strategies for making a lasting impression, and what should you look out for?

Understanding Recruitment Agencies

Understanding key recruitment agency insights can help you prepare to work with a recruiter and build a harmonious relationship. Remember that recruiters ultimately want to help you. Their skills allow them to procure the best candidates for different roles, and screening hundreds of candidates can be complicated and stressful.

Take it upon yourself to make the recruiter’s job easier and be proactive, asking questions about the company, its culture, the hiring lifecycle process, the ideal candidate, community outreach, and more. Ask recruiters for advice and allow them to share their knowledge with you to optimise your career potential.

Ask other questions, like what stands out about your resume and why the recruiter chose you to contact. Interviews go both ways when working with a recruiter, and it’s just as important for you to assess the recruiter as it is for them to assess you.

Recruitment agencies can also help you navigate resume and cover letter optimisation and offer useful tips for succeeding at your upcoming interviews. However, remember that agencies work for the employer, not for you. Inquire about their job opportunities before diving in head first to ensure you aren’t mismatched against the job criteria, and if you think the role is unsuitable, look elsewhere.

Strategies for Making a Lasting Impression

Following the right job hunting first impression tips can help you navigate the recruitment process like a pro. Consider the following when building relationships with recruiters and making your first impression.

Online Presence

More than likely, a recruiter’s first impression of you begins before you meet in person. Online presence for job seekers is a big component of whether or not a recruiter will see you as a viable candidate.

The impact of social media on job searches shouldn’t be underestimated – 55% of individuals using social media to research applicants have discovered content that caused them not to hire the applicant. There’s nothing worse than a recruiter finding your Facebook page only to see inappropriate and unprofessional content.

Before you start job hunting, Google yourself and get rid of anything a recruiter might find unsuitable.

Resume and Cover Letter

Your resume and cover letter are some of the most important factors in whether you get hired, so investing in a professional, tailored resume can significantly heighten your chances of getting hired.

With the economy tightening and job openings becoming more competitive, recruiters are flooded with resumes, and your resume should stand out from other applicants. Avoid jargon words like “detail-oriented” – be specific about your skills, show quantitative results of your efforts, and include industry-specific keywords to show your professional expertise.

Digital Presence and Professional Networking

Focusing on digital profile enhancement can help you stand out and garner interest from recruiters and employers. The role of the LinkedIn job search guide and other professional networks in making a lasting impression is massive, especially considering your digital presence is often the first way that recruiters connect with you.

Optimise your online profile and engage with industry professionals by taking advantage of the features these platforms offer. For instance, your LinkedIn profile can be enhanced using keyword optimisation, LinkedIn’s Open to Work feature, and professional posts highlighting your experience and expertise. Engaging with industry professionals online is a fantastic way to discover new opportunities.

Interview Preparation

The interview is one of the determining factors in whether you get hired, so following the right interview preparation techniques can make or break your chances of getting your dream job. Always arrive to interviews on time and prepared, and wear professional attire for interviews that suits the job’s culture. Bring all the materials you might need during the interview to show you’re prepared.

Ensure you’ve researched the company thoroughly before the interview. Don’t just look at their website – review their social media profiles, news articles, and other media coverage to get a sense of the business. If possible, speak with people in your network to understand the company culture better.

Come to any interview prepared to talk about yourself and your qualifications. The interviewer will want to know why you’re interested in the role, what you know about the company, and what skills make you the best candidate. Have work examples prepared that highlight your experience and success in the industry.

Practice responding to typical interview questions to feel more confident about the interview beforehand. Additionally, have a list of your top references available beforehand to ensure you can move forward in the hiring process.

During the Interview

Now comes the big step: getting interviewed for the role. Don’t feel like you have to skip the small talk – this stage lets people open up to you and emphasises authenticity in job interviews before getting to the more serious questions.

During the interview, be kind and confident. Use your nonverbal communication skills by extending the first handshake and indicating your enthusiasm about the position through nonverbal cues.

Beyond indicating interest through nonverbal cues, show your interest in the role by asking actionable questions about the organisation, your role, and the next steps of the hiring process. Plan your questions and talking points carefully, and before your interview, write down reasons why you’re the best candidate for the position, choosing words that align with what the employer is seeking.

Relate yourself to the company’s needs, highlighting a unique value proposition that separates you from other candidates. Whether you have a standout skill, diverse experience, or a fresh perspective, showing your unique value can help capture the attention of recruiters and employers.

Before the interview, minimise anything distracting, such as your phone – this will ensure nothing gets interrupted and ruins the natural flow of the interview.

Authenticity and Nonverbal Skills

Let’s look closer at the importance of nonverbal communication skills and authenticity in job interviews. During the interview, consider your body language and any nonverbal cues you send – for example, smiling throughout the interview shows that you’re friendly and positive, and nodding throughout the conversation shows that you’re paying attention and engaged.

During the interview, be your authentic self. Don’t exaggerate your achievements – focus on accurate answers and remain humble rather than boasting. This will help you appear genuine and help sell who you truly are.

Follow-Up and Building Relationships

Implementing follow-up strategies post-interview can help improve your chances of getting the job. Don’t take a wait-and-see approach after a final interview – continue showing interest even after the interview is over and during the final consideration stage.

You can follow up in several ways, such as sending personalised thank you emails to the people you interviewed with, connecting with the interviewer on LinkedIn, or sending a short follow-up email if you don’t hear back within a specific time frame.

Additionally, consider the following tips for maintaining a positive relationship with recruitment agencies:

  • Keep lines of communication open and promptly respond to messages and calls from recruitment agencies, even if you aren’t currently seeking a job.
  • Stay professional in all your communications, and treat agencies with courtesy.
  • Express your gratitude for the efforts of the recruitment agency during your interactions and after with a follow-up thank you email.
  • Stay engaged with the recruiters by participating in networking events, seminars, and workshops created by the recruitment agency.
  • Continuously update your resume and LinkedIn account to ensure recruiters have accurate information about your qualifications.

Always Respond, Even if You’re Not Looking

Not looking for a job right now? That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t respond to recruiters when they reach out. A recruitment agency reaching out to you means you might have the potential to grow your career with them when you’re looking for a new opportunity to expand your career.

When agencies connect with you, respond to their messages and let them know that, while you aren’t looking now, you’d be interested in learning more about opportunities as they arise.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Most of the suggestions above can be turned upside down into “not to do’s,” and avoiding common job search mistakes can help ensure your journey is successful. Some common mistakes that can harm your first impression include:

  • Not dressing appropriately
  • Not answering questions thoughtfully
  • Not asking questions
  • Not researching companies for job interviews
  • Not following up post-interview
  • Lack of confidence and poor interpersonal skills

Some other specific mistakes you might encounter include the following:

Speaking Negatively About Previous Employers

While you might not love all your previous job experiences, speaking negatively about a previous employer can significantly change a recruiter’s perspective on candidates. Companies want to hire problem solvers capable of overcoming tough or uncomfortable situations, so even if you’re discouraged about your current job, focus on what you’ve gained from the experience and the positives you can take from the position.

Using ‘We’ Instead of ‘I’

A common mistake seen again and again when getting feedback from clients is that candidates refer to their successes as something ‘we’ did instead of something ‘I’ did. Part of your personal branding for job hunting is being able to focus on what you’ve accomplished individually – so drop the ‘we’ statements and focus on what you’ve achieved in your career.

Find Jobs That Suit You

Recruiters play a massive role in the job hunting process, and making a lasting first impression on recruiters can make or break whether you get the job you’re hoping for. Some ways to make a lasting impression are optimising your online presence, improving your resume and cover letter, preparing for your interview, following up with interviewers, and always responding to recruiters, even if you aren’t looking for a job.

Finding a job that suits you is possible using skilled recruitment services. You can learn more about recruiters and job opportunities by taking advantage of WellsGray Recruitment’s resources for finding work today.

Speak with our Office Support Recruitment Experts